Debit Cards vs Credit Cards

by on Friday, October 16, 2009
Visa and Mastercard Debit Cards are becoming more popular. With adcampaigns like "spend your own money" and the misconception that because the card spends your own money you're safer, who wouldn't get on board?

But I ask you to take a real look at what the Debit Card is, and why you want a Credit Card instead.

Credit Cards are Safer.
Credit cards and debit cards are equally as easy to fraud. Once you have the card number buying something online with a fraudulent card is easy, just type in the number and away you go. There is nothing safer about having a debit card.

In fact having a credit card is safer. If someone uses your debit card to buy a $5,000 flat screen TV, that money will come straight out of your bank account, goodbye food for the next week or so. Sure you can apply to your card issuer to return the money because it was stolen, but that still takes time. If this happened with a credit card, the money would never come out of your account, as your card issuer could reverse the transaction easily before you have to pay for it.

Credit Cards Save You Money
Do you have a home loan with an offset account? Or an internet-only linked high interest account you can keep your money in? If you have either, you can make purchases on 55-day interest free credit card (all banks have one) putting the money you save into an offset account for your home loan, or into a high interest bank account. You'll easily make an extra $100 to $300 a year doing this, and if you have the home loan it'll save you that much off your interest!

But what about the idea: Credit Cards will make me spend too much money...
At the end of the day having a credit card won't make you spend anymore money than you would with a debit card. You just need some self control. It is possible to use a credit card only for purchases that you intend to payoff in full when the statement arrives, and as I've outlined above it's a heck of an advantage over the Debit card.

Unless you have a poor credit rating, or for some other reason are unable to acquire a Credit Card, there's no reason you shouldn't be using one instead of the deceiving Debit Cards that are becoming oh-so-popular. The key is to use a Credit Card like a Debit Card, only spend the money you already have and even set it aside as you use your Credit Card.

Note: If you can't control your spending, you should probably limit your access to money in any form that detaches you from how much money you really have.

I came across this today (25/11/2009), a visual and well done presentation on the pros and cons of both Credit Cards and Debit Cards, as well as an outline to the real physical risks of using a Debit Card.
Topics: , ,

11 comments:

  1. Sorry mate, couldn't get past the "your own money your safer".
    How old are you? Twelve? If you want to be taken seriously
    get your (not you're, yore or yaw) spelling and grammar up to
    scratch. Bet you like the word 'alot' a lot, too.
    ReplyDelete
  2. I like the way you leave the CRUX of the argument to the 'note' section right at the end and try to pass it off like it is nothing. Good going.
    ReplyDelete
  3. yep the note at the end is the number 1 reason I now use a debit card, I can't trust myself to manage a credit card.

    You also fail to mention that you pay interest on a credit card if you don't pay it off within 55 days.
    ReplyDelete
  4. This article is fundamentally wrong. Please disregard.
    ReplyDelete
  5. I don't see how post number 4 is relevant - insulting someone ("How old are you? Twelve?") about their grammar and spelling mistakes is just as childish.

    In any case, this advice is great for those who can control their spending as you can make a bit of extra cash on interest.

    I can't control my spending so unfortunately this doesn't apply to me :(
    ReplyDelete
  6. correction: post number 1
    ReplyDelete
  7. Be careful with Debit Cards... they're not as safe as Credit Cards
    ReplyDelete
  8. @goied

    Would *you* let a child tell you how to spend money? How
    about someone who says, "You just need some self control",
    can't be fagged learning decent English but does feel the
    need to post their great wisdom in blogs?

    People are tired of seeing 'there grammar' and words that are
    just plain *wrong* like 'alot' or even the amazingly moronic
    'allot'. It's a question of credibility. Go back to your
    PlayStations kids and stop bothering the adults.

    Anyway, how old *is* the author of this great work of research?
    ReplyDelete
  9. I never regard anyone who begins a sentence with "So" as being credible (or adult). This person has no concept of the distinction between credit and debit cards in a real world sense. Debit cards, when used for security, are NOT supposed to be attached to a primary bank account. They are supposed to be attached to a secondary bank account that money is transferred into as required. Banks provide "feeless" accounts for that purpose.
    ReplyDelete
  10. I'm sorry but this article is a complete load of rubbish.
    ReplyDelete
  11. Veritas, it doesn't matter if the account is a secondary account. If someone steals your debit card, they will then overdraw your account.

    You'll find most banks have clauses in their agreements that allow them to substitute a deficit in one of your accounts with a surplus in another account.

    And regardless, the overdraw will damage your credit rating.

    --

    Now if this was a credit card that was stolen, the owner would look at the statement, call the issuer of their card, report the fraud transaction, and the problem would be resolved. The card holder's credit rating would not be affected.
    ReplyDelete

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)